Choosing an Answer Engine Optimization (AEO) or Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) agency in India is harder than choosing an SEO agency. The results show up inside ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews, not in a rank tracker. This 12-point scorecard helps you separate agencies that can prove AI citations from agencies that have simply renamed their SEO packages.
Why choosing an AEO/GEO agency is different from choosing an SEO agency
Classic SEO has shared, public measures: rankings, organic traffic and backlinks. AEO and GEO don’t have them yet. An AI answer changes with the wording of the question, the platform, the user’s location and even the time of day. So an agency can claim “AI visibility” without much evidence.
That’s why the most important rule when evaluating an agency is simple: ask for citation evidence, not adjectives. A credible AEO/GEO agency should be able to show, for real queries, whether a brand is mentioned, cited or recommended inside AI-generated answers, and how that changed over time.
- AEO (Answer Engine Optimization): structuring content and data so AI answer engines and voice assistants pick your brand as the direct answer.
- GEO (Generative Engine Optimization): influencing how generative AI systems describe, compare and recommend your brand in written answers.
- Citation: your brand or URL appears as a named source or recommendation inside an AI-generated answer.
Before you start: build your own citation baseline
You can’t judge an agency’s claims without a baseline. This takes an afternoon:
- List 30–50 real buyer questions. Mix category questions (“best ERP for mid-size manufacturers in India”), comparisons (“X vs Y”) and problem questions (“how to reduce RTO in COD orders”).
- Run each question on the main platforms: ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews / AI Mode, Gemini, Perplexity and Microsoft Copilot. Use a clean browser session where you can.
- Record three things per answer: whether your brand is mentioned, whether your website is cited as a source, and which competitors appear instead.
- Save screenshots with dates. AI answers change, so dated evidence is the only fair way to compare before and after.
This baseline becomes the yardstick for every point on the scorecard below.
The 12-point AEO/GEO agency evaluation scorecard
Score each point from 0 to 2: 0 = no evidence, 1 = partial or claimed only, 2 = demonstrated with real data. The maximum score is 24.
1. Citation evidence from real queries
Ask for dated examples of AI answers where the agency’s clients are cited, with the exact query and platform. Score 2 only if they can show before-and-after evidence for the same queries.
2. A measurement method you can audit
How do they measure AI visibility? Look for a written method: query sets, platforms, testing frequency and how they handle answer variability. “Our proprietary score” with no method behind it scores 0.
3. Platform coverage
Do they test and optimise across ChatGPT, Gemini / Google AI Overviews, Perplexity and Copilot? Do they also cover Claude, Grok and Meta AI where these matter to your buyers? Each platform retrieves and cites sources differently, so coverage of one platform is not a strategy.
4. Entity and Knowledge Graph work
AI systems need to understand who you are before they can cite you. Strong agencies work on entity clarity: a consistent name, address and description across the web, a canonical “about” or brand-facts page, sameAs profiles, and presence in the knowledge sources AI models rely on.
5. Structured data competence
Ask them to review your current JSON-LD. A capable agency will spot common problems: missing Organization @id links, FAQ schema that doesn’t match the visible page, wrong areaServed types, broken breadcrumbs. Check that they validate with Google’s Rich Results Test and the Schema.org validator.
6. Answer-ready content capability
Can they restructure pages so answers are extractable? Look for direct-answer openings, question-led headings, concise definitions, comparison tables and FAQs written in the customer’s language. The aim is passages an AI system can quote accurately, not keyword density.
7. Technical AI-crawler readiness
Do they check whether AI crawlers can reach your site at all? This covers robots.txt rules for GPTBot, OAI-SearchBot, ClaudeBot and PerplexityBot; CDN bot protection that silently blocks AI fetchers; rendering issues; and llms.txt. Many brands are invisible simply because a firewall blocks the crawlers.
8. Industry and India-market understanding
AI answers for Indian buyers often involve local signals: cities, regional languages, GST and compliance context, and Indian marketplaces. An agency should understand how your category is discussed in India and in your export markets, if you sell abroad.
9. Competitor citation analysis
Ask: “Which competitors are cited for our top queries today, and why?” A strong agency can explain which sources the AI systems lean on (reviews, directories, publications, forums) and how to earn presence there.
10. Reporting cadence and transparency
Monthly reports should show the same query set over time, citation share per platform, competitor share, and what work was shipped. Be wary of reports that show only traffic or rankings. Those are SEO metrics, not AEO/GEO outcomes.
11. Honest scope and timelines
AI visibility usually builds over weeks and months, not days. Agencies that guarantee “#1 in ChatGPT” or fixed citation numbers score 0. No one controls a third-party AI model’s output. Credible agencies commit to work, method and measurement.
12. Commercial terms that protect you
Check lock-in periods, what happens to the content and schema if you leave (you should own them), whether audits are separate from retainers, and whether pricing is published or opaque. Shorter commitments with clear deliverables lower your risk while results are still being proven.
How to read the total score
| Score | What it means |
|---|---|
| 20–24 | Evidence-led AEO/GEO partner. Shortlist. |
| 14–19 | Capable but gaps in measurement or scope. Ask for a paid pilot with your baseline queries. |
| 8–13 | Mostly SEO with AEO language. Proceed only for SEO work. |
| 0–7 | No verifiable AI-visibility capability. |
Questions to ask in the first call
- Can you show three dated AI answers where a client was cited, with the query and platform?
- What’s your query set for a business like ours, and how often do you re-test it?
- Which of our competitors are cited today, and from which sources?
- What will you change in our structured data and entity setup in the first 30 days?
- What do we own if we stop working together?
Red flags
- Guaranteed rankings or citations inside ChatGPT or Gemini.
- “AI visibility scores” with no explained method.
- Reports that show only keyword rankings and traffic.
- No mention of entity, structured-data or crawler-access work.
- Long lock-ins before any baseline is measured.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between an AEO agency and an SEO agency?
An SEO agency mainly works to rank pages in traditional search results. An AEO/GEO agency works to get a brand mentioned, cited and recommended inside AI-generated answers on ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews. It relies on entity clarity, structured data and answer-ready content.
How do I verify an AEO agency’s results?
Build a baseline of 30–50 real buyer questions. Record whether your brand is mentioned or cited on each AI platform, with dated screenshots. Ask the agency to report against the same queries every month and to show dated before-and-after evidence.
How long does AEO or GEO take to show results?
It usually builds over weeks to months. The timing depends on your current entity signals, content quality, crawler access and competition. Be cautious of any agency that guarantees results within days.
Can an agency guarantee citations in ChatGPT or Gemini?
No. AI platforms are third-party systems that no agency controls. A credible agency commits to a method, measurable work and transparent reporting, not guaranteed placements.
What should an AEO/GEO agency cost in India?
Pricing varies with scope, number of platforms and content volume. Prefer agencies that publish their pricing, separate one-off audits from retainers, and avoid long lock-ins before a baseline is measured.
Disclosure: Netcloud India provides AEO and GEO services. This scorecard is written so you can apply it to any agency, including us. If you want a baseline audit, see the AI search audit.
Related services and guides
- Answer Engine Optimization (AEO) services
- Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) services
- AI search audit and AI visibility audit
- AEO and GEO pricing plans
- AI search case study: 3.8× LLM citation growth in 90 days
- 2026 AEO benchmark report for India
- 10 steps to get your brand cited in AI search
Further reading: Google Search Central: creating helpful, reliable content.


